|

Interview with Ann L. McLaughlin
author of The Balancing Pole
There have been some important developments in psychiatric
treatment since the late 1950s-the period in which The Balancing
Pole is set. Did you leave out these changes in drug treatment
for a reason?
Yes. I wanted to show the anguish and uncertainty that surrounded
both patient and doctor before the widespread use of tranquilizers
and especially before the advent of lithium carbonate, which
has had dramatic effects in alleviating the symptoms of manic-depression
in many patients.
The Balancing Pole is fiction, as is your first
novel. But is it actually drawn from your own experience?
Yes, although I have plunged further into fiction in this
novel than I did in my first, in order to shape the story and
give it a clarity that the experience of mental illness does
not have in the living of it, of course.
Your first novel, Lightning in July, deals with
a couple who survive the last polio epidemic in 1955. How would
you compare the pain of that physical illness with the pain of
the mental illness you describe in The Balancing Pole?
The physical pain of polio seemed almost tangible, while the
pain of mental illness, terrible as it is, seems far more elusive
and difficult to describe, partly because it is so often shrouded
by the heavy shame the patient feels at having failed certain
familial and societal expectations and needs. That shame and
guilt, which is not part of the polio victim's experience, can
exaggerate the pain of the mental patient to a terrible degree.
Why do you feel it's important to write and read about
experiences with mental illness?
Mental illness still evokes embarrassment for many people,
and yet almost everyone has had some experience of depression
or knows someone who has. And our resources for dealing with
these problems, though certainly better, are still limited. Thus
it seems important to me that we try to write and talk as honestly
as we can about what we know. Everyone's experience in this mysterious
business is different, but one person's story can shed a little
light on another's and can perhaps help some.
In both your first novel and in this one, you describe
people who survive a terrible physical or mental experience.
Are stories of survival important to you?
Yes, very. There are so many logical reasons why we might
not survive, and yet we do much of the time-surprising
ourselves with the discovery that we and our bodies are stronger
than we thought they were and that, when faced with a difficult
situation, we do have courage to go on.
Both you novels deal with women who survive. Do you feel
that women have a particular affinity for survival?
Yes. Obviously women are not the only survivors, but women
often have a special connection to the ongoing work of life that
helps them to survive. They are often the ones who feed and tend
and do the daily chores, and in the end it is often the daily
responsibilities, not the analytical insights, that hold people
in this life.
Your heroine in the Balancing Pole is a portrait
painter. Do you feel that artists run a greater risk of insanity?
No. Quite the opposite. I feel that the making of art, however
awkward and humble, and help to keep one sane.
Do you feel that writing can be therapeutic, or do you
feel that writing can be dangerously provocative for manic depressive
patients, as it was for Margo?
I think writing can be enormously therapeutic for almost anyone.
It can help to clarify your thoughts and stimulate others. Obviously
there are times in manic-depressive illness when writing is almost
too provocative, but I think it was probably better for Margo
to write than to try to talk out all of those thoughts, or, as
it turns out, try to convey them visually.
As a writing teacher, do you have any hints on how to transform
experiences like yours into art?
I recommend writing out actual memories initially in as much
detail as you can remember before you begin to shape them and
decide on the emphasis and meaning. Diaries and journals can
be very important in this early process.
How long did it take you to write The Balancing Pole?
I began it twenty-five years ago. I certainly haven't been
working at it continuously, but I've come back to it repeatedly
during that time, so that, among the several manuscripts I've
worked on, this is the one I've revised the most and have the
most versions of stacked in the attic.
Does the technique of multiple points of view in the novel
represent a mental state such as schizophrenia, or is it simply
a writing device?
It's really just a writing device. I wrote the story a number
of times solely from Margo's point of view, and it always seemed
to me that I got trapped in that depressed or fevered first person,
trapping the reader with me. The device of the several voices
of the family members, the neighbor, and the doctor allowed me
to circle the problem and lift the story out of the straight
case history format. Or so I hope.
Do you feel that the treatment Margo received in The
Balancing Pole was good, and do you mean the reader to infer
that she has recovered by the end?
Margo receives poor treatment initially from a rigid, inexperienced
doctor, but when she gets to the hospital she is treated with
compassion and her doctor has the wisdom to admit that neither
he nor any psychiatric resource as a real remedy to offer. In
the end, Margo recognizes that she is sick, but that if she watches
herself carefully she can live a fairly normal life. That realization
is crucial, and I mean it to signal a cautiously happy ending.
|